The Old Town Ice Cream Scene
Five ice cream shops within walking distance in Old Town Fort Collins. Which one deserves your visit?
Key Questions
Which Old Town shop has the best ice cream?
Which ones are locally owned vs. franchise?
What's the best shop for families?
In This Package
Josh & John's Ice Cream Review
Josh & John's has built a reputation for ultra-premium ice cream using local dairy from Colorado farms. Their Jessup Dr location features a convenient kiosk for grabbing pints and ice cream cakes.
Old Town Churn Review
Old Town Churn is the Fort Collins outpost of Denver's legendary Little Man Ice Cream. Located right in Old Town, it brings the same creative, small-batch approach that made Little Man a Denver icon.
Kilwins Review
Kilwins is a national franchise known for its fudge, chocolates, and ice cream. Their Old Town Fort Collins location benefits from heavy foot traffic and offers a sweet-shop experience beyond just scoops.
Ben & Jerry's Review
Ben & Jerry's needs no introduction. Their Fort Collins scoop shop in Old Town Square serves the same beloved flavors you know from grocery stores, plus exclusive shop-only options.
Reading Order
Follow this path for the complete picture.
The Weekly Scoop
Fort Collins ice cream news, new flavor alerts, and seasonal guides.
Newsletter delivery is being prepared. Subscribe to receive it when it launches.
By subscribing, I agree to receive the Weekly Scoop newsletter from Ice Cream Magazine. I can unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy
Free · Unsubscribe anytime